A court in Sudbury, Ont., has awarded an embryo to a woman in a case involving her ex-husband, in what is being called a precedent-setting decision because the embryo has no biological connection to the couple.
Two childhood friends decided to get married in 2009 to have and raise children together, but the man didn't want his sperm used and the woman's eggs weren't suitable. So three years later, they purchased eggs and sperm from a business in the United States for $11,500 US, and two good embryos were created through in-vitro fertilization.
The judge's decision awarding the embryo to the woman, who is now 48, was released last week.
It hinged on a consent form from a fertility clinic in southern Ontario on which the couple indicated the "patient's wishes" would be honoured in case of divorce. The form describes the woman receiving the embryo as "the patient."
Where are we at with fertility treatment and law in Canada, and where are we headed? CBC's Christine Birak put your questions to a fertility doctor and a lawyer about access to fertility treatment 40 years after the first test tube baby was born.
"The justice said you're not allowed to change your mind," said Dale Brawn, lawyer for the woman.
"To paraphrase the judge's words, no buyer's remorse. When you sign a contract saying how an embryo will be used, then that contract is enforceable."
The man's lawyers had argued that the consent form from the egg bank in the United States trumped the one filled out at the Canadian fertility clinic.
They also argued that the man paid for the embryo, so it was his property, and that the woman "refuses to be gainfully employed," so didn't have the finances to support a larger family.
"This is to my mind the first time there is a clear decision in Canada that comes right out and says when there is no genetic connection, embryos are to be treated as property," said Toronto fertility lawyer Sara Cohen, commenting about the case.
"(We're) slowly building toward this understanding that we're going to deal with embryos, perhaps, as a less special category."
Brawn said his client plans to carry the second embryo and have a second child. She doesn't plan to seek child support.
"What really strikes me is what a blunt instrument the law is for dealing with complex issues such as this," said University of Toronto bioethicist Kerry Bowman.
Bowman doesn't necessarily disagree with the ruling, but wonders if consent forms are the best way to make decisions in such complex, emotional cases.
"True consent from an ethical point of view would be a deep, deep reflection on some of these questions."
Cohen said this also sets the stage for landmark embryo custody cases that lawyers such as herself have been waiting for — when a court makes a clear decision on who gets an embryo that has a biological connection to one or both sides in a divorce.
Latest USA News
- Inside the horror
- Three-year youth sentence for teen in beating death of Serena McKay
- Child is province's first confirmed case of West Nile virus this year
- Community club to rebuild after fire
- Human remains found at Sagkeeng identified
- Federal environment minister praises Manitoba, criticizes Ontario
- Portage la Prarie gets first new hotel in 30 years
- Squires to keep reproductive-rights file
- 'Unexpected' repairs to choke one of city's major routes
- Shortage of anesthesiologists in Manitoba causing surgery cancellations
- Sharing stories from here, our home
- Refugee's success shows potential of young newcomers
- Ready to launch
- Private practice
- Ferry held hostage until First Nation's problems addressed
- Blue stroll over watered-down Esks
- Time, fire erase last visible ties to community builder
- Former gridiron standout Idonije writes stories encouraging youngsters to be the best they can be
- Former attorney general Roland Penner dead at 93
- Playbook: Caps take 2-1 Cup series lead, Tkachuk a hot NHL prospect, Tiger lurking at Memorial and more...
- Mental illness cited in deaths of Steinbach father and son
- Brrrrr-utal! Spring temperatures likely weeks away
- Wheeler, muckers lead way to victory
- Civil trials moving at brisker pace
- Taking a stand against harassment
- City eyes traffic lights at site of fatal collision
- Winnipeg has love affair with horror
- Waste not, want not
- A valuable space, lost in litigation
- Free Press Head Start for April 3
- Secret life of plants making music
- Ex-Hydro chairman refutes premier
- Wire-to-wire world champ
- Optimism shines bright at upbeat Juno Awards show in Vancouver
- Canada joins U.S., Europe in expelling Russian spies for British poison attack
- Feds ease restrictions on prescription heroin to address opioid epidemic
- Mexico official: Iowa family died from water heater gas leak
- White House: Trump thinks Stormy Daniels lied about threat
- Developer to alter Pembina Highway apartment plans
- It's a great time to be a sports fan in Winnipeg